Cooling Water
Corrosion Control
Puckorius AS-8150 test
Puckorius AS-8310 test
Product & MSDS Sheets
Treatment Comparison:
AS-8310 vs. Zinc Orthophosphate
Drinking Water
Introduction
Theory
Lab Tests
Results
Tin Toxicity
Comparisons
Lead Corrosion Study
University of Minnesota
World Health Organization Report:
Tin and Inorganic Tin Compounds
Resources
Case Histories
Site Directory
Contact AS Inc
|
AS-8150 compared to other corrosion control methods
| Corrosion Control Method |
| |
AS-8150 |
pH Control |
Alkalinity Adjustment |
Phosphates |
Silicates |
| Ease of Use |
Ready to use |
Ready to use |
Facilities required to prepare |
Ready to use |
Ready to use |
| Feed Equipment |
Chemical feed pump |
Storage tank and pumps |
Dry handling and make down |
Chemical feed pump |
Storage tanks and pump |
| Cost of Equipment |
Minimal |
Moderate |
Expensive |
Minimal |
Moderate |
| Effectiveness |
Effective |
Sometimes |
Sometimes |
Effective |
Ineffective |
| Ease of Start-up |
Easy, gradual |
Tricky, must be slow |
Can cause red water |
Can cause red water |
Can be tricky |
| Nutrients |
No |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
No |
| Environmentally Friendly |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Can cause algae blooms |
Yes |
| Dosage Required |
0.175 PPM or less |
Variable |
Variable |
1 - 3 PPM as PO4 |
25 - 40 PPM |
Copyright © asi-corrosioncontrol.com 2005 to
All rights reserved worldwide |
|